Evidence-Based Mental Health Treatments: Lost in Translation

Posted on by

Earlier this month I attended a conference sponsored by the MacArthur Foundation spotlighting the intersection of mental health and public policy. In introductory comments for the event, Howard Goldman, Professor of Psychiatry at the University of Maryland School of Medicine and director the MacArthur Foundation’s Network on Mental Health Policy Research, called mental illness “an overlooked crisis.” He’s right. But contrary to what you might expect, it’s not just the public which overlooks mental health. Medical practitioners are often slow to adopt well-researched, proven mental health interventions—because they’re rarely profitable.

This is bad news for America, because mental illness is a big problem. Goldman noted that 38 percent of Americans who receive Social Security Disability Insurance have a mental disorder, as do more than 200,000 adults in prison and 30 percent of the nation’s homeless.

But mental illness isn’t just an issue for the have-nots. Jon Fanton, Ph.D., President of the MacArthur Foundation, addressed the conference after Goldman and offered some compelling numbers on the fiscal impact of poor mental health. Every year, said Fanton, mental illness amounts to $80 billion in indirect costs (lost productivity due to illness, premature death, and losses for incarcerated individuals and for individuals providing family care) and another $99 billion in the direct cost of providing care. Fully half of children with mental illnesses drop out of school.

For these reasons, said Fanton, the “interests of those in trouble are not in contrast to the interests of society and or the rest of us”—though “we tend to think…[that] the opposite is actually true.” In the end, mental health is a very public concern.

Given this fact, you’d think that health care practitioners would make
it a priority to provide effective mental health treatment. But a 2005 study
from the National Institutes of Mental Health (NIMH) and Harvard found
that only one-third of mental health therapies received by patients
meet minimal standards for adequacy as established in national
guidelines. That means that when we know what works—and even draw up
guidelines to define best practices—relatively few providers follow the
rules. Why is it so hard to translate knowledge into practice?

Three academics—Robert Drake, M.D. and Jonathan Skinner, Ph.D from Dartmouth Medical School, along with Goldman—wrote an issue brief for the conference that looked at his very question. Their conclusion? It’s all about the money.

According to the authors, most effective mental health treatment
regimes are not purely medication-based but also involve psychosocial
intervention—that is, a program of cognitive and behavioral measures
such as patient education, psychotherapy, and peer support. Unlike
medication, which changes body chemistry, psychosocial treatments are
focused on changing the way patients view themselves and their
relationship to others and their environment.

By way of example, consider cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), a
particularly well-researched kind of psychosocial intervention. The
University of Michigan Depression Center (UMDC) offers an overview of how CBT would be applied to someone suffering from clinical depression:

“The first [component of CBT,] cognitive restructuring, involves
collaboration between the patient and the therapist to identify and
modify habitual errors in thinking that are associated with depression.
Depressed patients often experience distorted thoughts about themselves
(e.g. I am stupid), their environment (e.g. My life is terrible) and
their future (e.g. There is no sense in going forward, nothing will
work out for me). Information from the patient’s current experience,
past history, and future prospects is used to counter these distorted
thoughts.

“In addition to self-critical thoughts, patients with depression
typically cut back on activities that have the potential to be
enjoyable to them, because they anticipate that such activities will
not be worth their effort. Unfortunately this usually results in a
vicious cycle, wherein depressed mood leads to less activity, which in
turn results in further depressed mood, etc.

“The second component of CBT, behavioral activation, seeks to remedy
this downward spiral by negotiating gradual increases in potentially
rewarding activities with the patient. When patients are depressed,
problems in daily living often seem insurmountable. In the final
process, the CBT therapist provides instruction and guidance in
specific strategies for solving problems (e.g. breaking problems down
into small steps).”

Given CBT’s focus on self-esteem, perspective, and encouragement, it
might come off as somewhat touchy-feely to the outside observer—but in
fact it’s proven to be quite effective.

The UMDC notes that 75 percent of patients who undergo CBT show significant improvements. A 2000 NEJM study showed
that the most effective depression treatment for adults is a
combination of CBT and medication, which produced a response or
remission in 73 percent of patients involved (versus 48 percent for CBT
or antidepressants alone). A NIMH-funded study
from earlier this month paints an even more flattering picture of CBT,
showing that of 242 depressive teens, 74 percent who received
medication-only treatment sustained improvement over 36 weeks, compared
to 89 percent who received both medication and CBT—and a whopping 97 percent of those who only received CBT treatment.

CBT is clearly an important component of effective interventions for
depressed patients—yet, relative to purely medicinal treatments, it’s
proven unpopular. A 2002 JAMA study
found that between 1987 and 1997 the proportion of patients who used
antidepressant medication climbed by 38 points, while the proportion
who received cognitive therapy dropped by nine points. Even as
a greater share of patients received treatment in the form of
prescription drugs, fewer received alternative interventions.

Even  though the FDA issued a warning about prescribing antidepressants
to children in 2004—causing a dip in prescription rates—psychosocial
treatments haven’t seen a boost. A 2007 study
from the American Journal of Psychiatry found that, even though the
proportion of diagnosed kids who went without antidepressants has
increased “to three times the rate predicted by the pre-advisory trend”
since the FDA warning, there is “no evidence of a significant increase
in use of treatment alternatives” including psychosocial programs.

Why can’t psychosocial treatments seem to catch a break? “Unlike new
medications, where the marketing of new practices is supported and
encouraged by patents,” notes Drake et al. in their issue brief,
“psychosocial treatments are not patented and therefore lack the
economic incentives to promote them widely. Because it is difficult to
market, doctors are less exposed to best practice strategies and
consumers are often unaware of other strategies for treatment.”

Speaking about this issue in person during a panel at the conference,
Drake didn’t mince words, noting that “no one makes a profit off
psychosocial interventions, so they are used less often.” Moreover, a
treatment like CBT is not quick and easy: it’s sequential,
collaborative, and personalized. In short, it’s messy, labor
intensive—and thus hard to sell. As one audience member pointed out
during a Q & A session, “I haven’t seen any media that says ‘ask
your doctor about peer supports…’”

Drake went on to note that, due in part to complexity of such
interventions, less than 5 percent of people with a serious mental
illness get access to evidence-based treatment—much of which includes
interventions other than drugs.

No doubt much of the remaining 95 percent get prescription drugs. Lots
of prescription drugs. “The products that are producing a profit for
companies tend to be oversold,” said Drake before the audience. “This
just gets worse and worse now that we have DTC [direct-to-consumer
advertising], and now that the [prescription drug] industry has figured
out that [it] can have very strong effects on doctors and other
prescribers through a variety of [marketing] techniques.”

We now know that the drug industry spends more on advertising and
marketing than it does on research and development; but there is only a
limited number of dollars in the treatment pool, which means that the
more medication is aggressively peddled, the “less money [we are able
to put] in[to] other effective services.” The din of Big Pharma’s
marketing often drowns out other voices—and other treatment options. 

Perhaps the worst part of all this is that the money that goes into
medications is often wasted. It often funds drugs that, as Drake noted,
are so poorly researched that “we find out years later that they are
not as effective” as their manufacturers claim.

Here on Health Beat we’ve pointed out
how drug companies distort statistics to make their products seem more
effective than they really are, or how once-sacred assumptions—like the
notion that everyone with high cholesterol should be on statins–—are in fact untrue.  In many cases the risks may outweigh the benefits. 

Unfortunately, similar tales of over-marketing exist in the mental
health sphere. In their issue brief, Drake and his co-authors call
attention to the case of second generation schizophrenia drugs (such as
Zyprexa, Seroquel, and Risperdal), which target a different set of
chemical receivers than traditional medications and which “were
aggressively marketed in the early 2000s.”

“Prices for these medications were ten times those of the
first-generation drugs—a key reason behind more aggressive marketing
and sales,” the authors point out. “Consequently, expenditures for
these second-generation medications in the United States rose to $2.6
billion in 2003, accounting for 71 percent of users and 93 percent of
total expenditures for antipsychotics.”

But over the past few years, multiple “longer-term, well controlled studies
found that the new second-generation antipsychotic medications are no
more effective than the older antipsychotics.” Perhaps even more
strikingly, a 2000 study
in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry found that CBT was just as
effective as these newer schizophrenia drugs. In other words, billions
of dollars were spent for nothing.

Thus the problem isn’t only that psychosocial interventions don’t get a
lot of attention; it’s also that the medications that do get the
attention—and the money—are often profoundly ineffective. Precious
resources are sucked away from proven treatments and funneled to
ineffective drugs.

It would be wrong to say that, were drug companies to become less
aggressive, practitioners would leap at the chance to implement
psychosocial interventions. The truth is that programs like CBT are
labor-intensive and the overhead is expensive. Speaking at the
conference, Drake noted that “well-researched interventions that are
highly effective [tend to be] grossly under-utilized because they
involve some start-up funds and reorganization.”

This is an easy point to understand. Research that proves a new drug is
effective can garner a quick—albeit sometimes expensive—response from
providers: prescribe the drug. But translating research on the efficacy
of CBT into practice might require an organizational overhaul
additional staffing, or the development of new therapy programs. These
are not burdens that health care organizations are eager to take up.

In the end however, Drake notes that interventions with high up-front
costs will actually save money “across years and over problems” by
improving our aggregate mental health and reducing that gargantuan
price tag of direct and indirect costs.

Yet like so much else in our health care system, the dynamics
surrounding mental health treatments favor short-term profits over
long-term solutions. And so “best practices” aren’t practiced.

72 thoughts on “Evidence-Based Mental Health Treatments: Lost in Translation”

  1. Yes, you are correct, mental illness is an overlooked crisis, not only by the general public but also by the Medical practitioners. You have well exposed this problem in your Article. Thanks!
    __________________
    Beth W.
    Universal Health Care & Medical Tourism
    Is it possible to create universal health through medical tourism? Or does it just create a brain drain that benefits wealthy travelers? Maybe it’s too soon to tell.
    http://www.healism.com/

  2. Excellent. Nikko and Maggie, you two are rapidly turning your blog into the most thoughtful, best informed one in the health policy blogosphere.

  5. Thanks for a great — and timely — entry. This isn’t like to change any time soon, but it’s good that at least people are noticing the problem….

  6. MedBlog Power 8

    04/23/2008 – 04/30/2008Next revision: 04/30/2008
    (Key: Rank, Blog name, Last week’s rank, Post of note)
    1) Aggravated DocSurg (-), We Don’t Speak the Same Lingo

  7. The study of depressed teens was the Treatment of Adolescents with Depression Study (TADS). The teens were randomized to 1 of 3 treatments for 36 weeks — Prozac, CBT, or both. By week 12, the combination group achieved the highest rate of sustained response (71%), compared to the Prozac-only group (68%) and the CBT-only group (42%). Of the teens who reached a sustained positive response by week 12, the following percentages maintained improvement through week 36: 89% of the combination group, 74% of the Prozac-only group, and 97% of the CBT-only group. The 97% for the CBT-only group is very good, but remember that is 97% of the kids who had responded by week 12, which was only 42%.
    Marilyn Mann

  8. Overall, I do agree with the gist of your article here, but there are some fairly major factual errors which detract from the credibility of the posting. Marilyn Mann already mentioned the misuse of the 97% figure for teens sustaining improvement in the TADs study. Later in the post, you say: “Perhaps even more strikingly, a 2000 study in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry found that CBT was just as effective as these newer schizophrenia drugs. In other words, billions of dollars were spent for nothing.” In actuality, this study compared CBT with antidepressants, not with antipsychotics. CBT has, in some studies, been shown as effective as drugs for mild to moderate depression, but it has never been shown to be as effective as antipsychotics for schizophrenia.

  9. MedBlog Power 8

    04/23/2008 – 04/30/2008Next revision: 04/30/2008
    (Key: Rank, Blog name, Last week’s rank, Post of note)
    1) Aggravated DocSurg (-), We Don’t Speak the Same Lingo

  10. MedBlog Power 8

    04/23/2008 – 04/30/2008Next revision: 04/30/2008
    (Key: Rank, Blog name, Last week’s rank, Post of note)
    1) Aggravated DocSurg (-), We Don’t Speak the Same Lingo

  11. [url=http://www.coolingame.com]wow power leveling[/url]
    [url=http://www.coolingame.com]wow powerleveling[/url]
    [url=http://www.coolingame.com]world of warcraft power leveling[/url]

  13. Thanks a lot, this is really helpful. Really well for me and I’m not going back to the proprietary guys! If You Need More Information Please Visit us :- eTranslate is an international company specialising in the provision of Internationalization and Globalization Solutions.

  16. Hi guys this is James here.The treatment of mental disorders dates back to ancient civilisations, including Ancient Egypt, India, Greece and Rome. Medieval physicians in the Muslim world from the 8th to 15th centuries were concerned with mental health.
    James
    Maryland Drug Treatment

  21. Your article is very nice and with this we can treat for mental illness and one more is if we restrict drugs by taking severe actions on drug makers, dealers and sellers then also we can decrease the mental illness.
    =======================
    Franklin
    [url=http://www.addictionlink.org/drug-rehab-center/maryland ]maryland drug rehab [/url]

  22. Thanks for a great — and timely — entry. This isn’t like to change any time soon, but it’s good that at least people are noticing the problem….

  23. Of the teens who reached a sustained positive response by week 12, the following percentages maintained improvement through week 36: 89% of the combination group, 74% of the Prozac-only group, and 97% of the CBT-only group. The 97% for the CBT-only group is very good, but remember that is 97% of the kids who had responded by week 12, which was only 42%.
    http://www.online-flash-game.com/ flash games

  24. Even in the absence of these situations, an intervention can be successful especially if the family is close to the addict on a daily basis so that every little situation is known by the family. An addict’s life can be a major roller coaster and the only way an addict can deny their problem is to successfully hide these problems from those who love him.
    _____
    Drug Intervention

  28. Services usually buy my games. But every time I go http://www.ygscn.net. Because every time they did not disappoint me, for me to provide excellent service. Therefore, I hope that everyone can go take a look at their Warhammer Online Power Leveling and Warhammer Online Gold. They have many excellent Game Games gold and technology. At the same time, the form of the face of the economic benefits they introduce more and more every player fit for wow power leveling and wow gold service. also Service there is more to choose from: AOC Gold, SilkRoad Online gold, SWG credits, WAR Power leveling, EQ2 gold.

  30. world of warcraft power leveling wow power leveling power leveling wow gold 橡塑发泡 直流电源 paper cup machine Mass air flow 程控交换机 餐饮软件 餐饮软件 收银机 automatic rigid box line paper converting and wrapping machines automatic box makers rigid set-up gift box,paperboard converting equipment
    气动马达 气动搅拌机 防爆马达 防爆搅拌机 气动搅拌机 空气马达 防爆马达 气动马达 油漆搅拌机 油漆搅拌器 气动搅拌器 防爆搅拌器 油墨搅拌器 油墨搅拌机 安检门 金属探测器 金属探测仪 thermoforming Equipment bag making machine 工业设计 产品设计 储罐 中药提取设备 乳化机 反应釜 真空干燥箱 厚壁钢管
    power leveling wow power leveling paper box paper box equipment thermoforming Equipment Plastic Machinery Plastic Machine 马达 气动马达 搅拌机

  32. world of warcraft power leveling wow power leveling power leveling wow gold 橡塑发泡 直流电源 paper cup machine Mass air flow 程控交换机 餐饮软件 餐饮软件 收银机 automatic rigid box line paper converting and wrapping machines automatic box makers rigid set-up gift box,paperboard converting equipment
    气动马达 气动搅拌机 防爆马达 防爆搅拌机 气动搅拌机 空气马达 防爆马达 气动马达 油漆搅拌机 油漆搅拌器 气动搅拌器 防爆搅拌器 油墨搅拌器 油墨搅拌机 安检门 金属探测器 金属探测仪 thermoforming Equipment bag making machine 工业设计 产品设计 储罐 中药提取设备 乳化机 反应釜 真空干燥箱 厚壁钢管
    power leveling wow power leveling paper box paper box equipment thermoforming Equipment Plastic Machinery Plastic Machine 马达 气动马达 搅拌机

  33. I know a very interesting rpg game worldfowarcraft. A lot of my
    friends are playing this game. They need more wow gold to make their
    hero in game more powerful, more attractive and more charming.
    They use wow gold to
    buy more powerful equipments. They told me they often buy wow gold
    from Masswowgold
    , since Masswowgold provide cheap wow gold and good
    service to players. Now,
    masswowgold is offering consumer cards to old customers.
    Customers will save much more money when they buy wow gold with
    consumer
    cards . Customers also can earn money through our affiliate
    program .
    Some of my friend also play other games, like silkroad online gold , Lineage
    1 adena , sro gold
    and silkroad online gold .
    They often buy the gold from Supgold, also a very professional
    gold selling site. Players can buy cheap SRO gold , wow gold and silkroad gold there.
    新需能
    新需能电池
    电动车电池
    电动车蓄电池
    电瓶车蓄电池

  36. I should have to buy red war gold to alert from just that but I could not help but take his offer for him to show it to me in action. So he took me out to the redwar gold and dug up a hidden dungeon called Behemoth. Then I saw a guy, he had nothing but rare clothes and a little red war gold. I talked to him for a while and after a bit I tried to charm 250K to buy redwar gold out of him.

  38. Yesterday afternoon, the city’s defense held Guangzhou Water No. 15 typhoon of this year, “Crater” situation Lash. Learned that the “Crater” Yesterday’s 7:00 wow goldin Taishan city, town, North steep landing. Affected by the typhoon, Guangzhou City, appeared in a wind gust of more than eight urban heavy rains, localized heavy rain to heavy rain, and hit a 20-year return period storm surge high-water mark, Pearl River Maximum sea level 2.6 meters, 1.1 wow power leveling meters above the danger level.

  41. “Macross”
    [url=http://shop.brandsuper.com/nike-air-max-shoes-nike-air-max-2009-shoes-c-54_71.html%5Dair max 2009[/url]There Miki Haruhiko be carried out by the present set up, and his style fresh, delicate brushwork, color, feeling very superior, the screen [url=http://shop.brandsuper.com/nike-basketball-shoes-kobe-bryant-shoes-c-238_245.html%5Dkobe bryant shoes[/url] is always filled with a sense of light perception and transparent, warm and cold colors and lighting effect is very prominent. [url=http://shop.brandsuper.com/nike-basketball-shoes-c-238.html%5Dnike basketball shoes[/url]
    In addition to these characters and story lines, animated the deformation [url=http://shop.brandsuper.com/nike-basketball-shoes-lebron-james-shoes-c-238_246.html%5DLebron James Shoes[/url]of fighter that could be printed will be the long-term “super” fans of the brain, these prototypes to the U.S.

  44. It was a very nice idea! Just wanna say thank you for the information you have shared. Just continue writing this kind of post. I will be your loyal reader. Thanks again.

  48. 091016114731AMbuy maplestory mesos | MapleStory mesos | MapleStory gold | cheap maplestory mesos |

  52. I know a very interesting rpg game worldfowarcraft. A lot of my
    friends are playing this game. They need more wow gold to make their

  60. Do you want to make moreAirRivals spi,now listen to me carefully. As long as you have time, play the game kaos warAirRivals gold will be easy gotten. You also can sell some equipment to get thebuy AirRivals spiThe other way is tobuy AirRivals goldthencheap AirRivals.

  64. Nada disso!O verdadeiro segredo é a Sabedoria.
    Comecem cedo a aprender e serão irresistíveis. Gatos menos cultos teem de fazer coisas ordinárias para se reproduzirem, não sei se acompanharam a saga daquele Cristiano Ronaldo que muitas dizem ser um Gato, pobre felino teve de comprar um filho, sabem porquê? Nunca Leu!
    É por essas e outras que já aqui estou à espera dos miúdos para as aulas da manhã! Vão ser Gatos instruídos, olá se vão.

Comments are closed.